Gated stress-only 99mTc myocardial perfusion SPECT imaging accurately assesses coronary artery disease.

In today's cost containment environment it is important to consider changes to standard protocols which would reduce cost, particularly if there is no significant loss of diagnostic accuracy. The aim of the present study was to assess the usefulness of a gated stress-only Tc sestamibi protocol in comparison to conventional gated dual isotope rest-stress myocardial perfusion single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) in the detection and localization of coronary artery disease (CAD). Sixty-five consecutive patients (65+/-10 years, 22 women) who had undergone conventional gated perfusion SPECT were chosen retrospectively. Fifty-three of these 65 patients had previous coronary arteriography, 45 with at least one stenosis, eight without stenosis, and 12 of these 65 patients had <5% likelihood of CAD. Three readers interpreted the gated stress-only and dual isotope studies in separate sessions blinded to (1). their previous readings, (2). the interpretation by others, and (3). the angiographic results. Readers used a five-point scale to score their visual and quantitative assessment of perfusion, function and compromised vascular territory. Their average score was used for determination of the accuracy by using receiver operating characteristic (ROC) analysis of the techniques. The areas under ROC curves were determined for the detection of CAD and localization of vascular territories. Fifty-four of these patients had 97 significant stress induced perfusion defects as determined by the CEqual quantitative program. The agreement between protocols for the assessment of reversibility in these 97 defects was analysed. There were no statistically significant differences between dual isotope rest/stress and gated stress-only studies for the detection and localization of CAD. The area under the dual isotope rest/stress ROC curve was 0.78+/-0.07 compared to the area under the gated stress-only ROC curve of 0.80+/-0.06, resulting in P=0.30. For the combined vessels comparison of the area under the dual isotope rest/stress ROC curve was 0.73+/-0.04 versus the area under the gated stress-only ROC curve of 0.74+/-0.04, resulting in P=0.27. Similar non-significant differences were obtained when comparing the area under the dual isotope versus gated stress-only ROC curves for the left anterior descending vascular territory (LAD, 0.61+/-0.08 vs 0.660.08, P=0.14), the left circumflex vascular territory (LCX, 0.82+/-0.07 vs 0.81+/-0.06, P =0.47) or the right coronary vascular territory (RCA, 0.80+/-0.06 vs 0.78+/-0.06, P=0.28). The analysis of the reversibility of stress induced perfusion defects yielded a global agreement between protocols of 93% (kappa=0.42). The differences were due to the expert readers, using the gated stress-only protocol, misinterpreting some patients with attenuation artefacts, subendocardial infarction and functional stunning. These results show that the lower cost gated stress-only myocardial Tc myocardial perfusion SPECT studies are comparable to the conventional dual isotope studies when the clinical question is the detection and localization of coronary artery disease. Nevertheless, we also showed that this approach is limited when attempting to interpret the reversibility of stress induced perfusion defects in patients who exhibit attenuation artefacts, subendocardial infarction and functional stunning.

Evaluation of left ventricular endocardial volumes and ejection fractions computed from gated perfusion SPECT with magnetic resonance imaging: comparison of two methods.

BACKGROUND: Two methods of computing left ventricular volumes and ejection fraction (EF) from 8-frame gated perfusion single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) were compared with each other and with magnetic resonance (MR) imaging. METHODS AND RESULTS: Thirty-five subjects underwent 8-frame gated dual-isotope SPECT imaging and 12- to 16-frame gated MR imaging. Endocardial boundaries on short-axis MR images were hand traced by experts blinded to any SPECT results. Volumes and EF were computed with the use of Simpson's rule. SPECT images were analyzed for the same functional variables with the use of 2 automatic programs, Quantitative Gated SPECT (QGS) and the Emory Cardiac Toolbox (ECTb). The mean difference between MR and SPECT EF was 0.008 for ECTb and 0.08 for QGS. QGS showed a slight trend toward higher correlation for EF (r = 0.72, SE of the estimate = 0.08) than ECTb (r = 0.70, SE of the estimate = 0.09). For both SPECT methods, left ventricular volumes were similarly correlated with MR, although SPECT volumes were higher than MR values by approximately 30%. CONCLUSIONS: QGS and ECTb values of cardiac function computed from 8-frame gated perfusion SPECT correlate very well with each other and correlate well with MR. Averaged over all subjects, ECTb measurements of EF are not significantly different from MR values but QGS significantly underestimates the MR values.

Diagnostic performance of an expert system for the interpretation of myocardial perfusion SPECT studies.

UNLABELLED: An expert system (PERFEX) developed for the computer-assisted interpretation of myocardial perfusion SPECT studies is now becoming widely available. To date, a systematic validation of the diagnostic performance of this expert system for the interpretation of myocardial perfusion SPECT studies has not been reported. METHODS: To validate PERFEX's ability to detect and locate coronary artery disease (CAD), we analyzed 655 stress/rest myocardial perfusion prospective SPECT studies in patients who also underwent coronary angiography. The patient population comprised CAD patients (n = 480) and healthy volunteers (n = 175) (449 men, 206 women). Data from 461 other patient studies were used to implement and refine 253 heuristic rules that best correlated the presence and location of left ventricular myocardial perfusion defects on SPECT studies with angiographically detected CAD and with human expert visual interpretations. Myocardial perfusion defects were automatically identified as segments with counts below sex-matched normal limits. PERFEX uses the certainty of the location, size, shape, and reversibility of the perfusion defects to infer the certainty of the presence and location of CAD. The visual interpretations of tomograms and polar maps, vessel stenosis from coronary angiography, and PERFEX interpretations were all accessed automatically from databases and were used to automatically generate comparisons between diagnostic approaches. RESULTS: Using the physician's reading as a gold standard, PERFEX's sensitivity and specificity levels for detection and localization of disease were, respectively, 83% and 73% for CAD, 76% and 66% for the left anterior descending artery, 90% and 70% for the left circumflex artery, and 74% and 79% for the right coronary artery. These results were extracted from a receiver operating characteristic curve using the average optimal input certainty factor. CONCLUSION: This study shows that the diagnostic performance of PERFEX for interpreting myocardial perfusion SPECT studies is comparable with that of nuclear medicine experts in detecting and locating CAD.

Clinical impact of arrhythmias on gated SPECT cardiac myocardial perfusion and function assessment.

BACKGROUND: We reported previously that mean quantified cardiac functional parameters computed by one gated single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) technique were not significantly altered by common gating errors. However, it is not known to what extent other gated SPECT approaches that are based on different ventricular modeling assumptions are influenced by arrhythmias, nor are the effects of gating errors on visual analyses and their subsequent clinical implications known. METHODS: Projection data for 50 patients (aged 64 +/- 12 years; 68% men; 76% with myocardial perfusion defects) undergoing technetium-99m sestamibi gated SPECT who were in sinus rhythm during data acquisition were altered to simulate common arrhythmias. To determine quantitative effects, we performed calculations for original control and altered images by Gaussian myocardial detection (Quantitative Gated SPECT [QGS] program) and by wall thickening derived from gated perfusion polar maps (Emory Cardiac Toolbox program). To evaluate visual assessment in control and simulated-arrhythmia tomograms, 2 experienced blinded observers independently interpreted perfusion from polar maps and wall motion and thickening from tomographic cines, using a 4-point scale. RESULTS: Although mean functional parameters were scarcely altered, paired t tests showed ejection fraction fluctuations to be significantly different from control values, causing patients to change between abnormal and normal ejection fraction categories (2% of patients by QGS and 14% by Emory Cardiac Toolbox). Visual examination of QGS polar perfusion and function maps showed changes for 72% of cases, although in only 4% were these considered to have potential clinical consequences. The kappa statistic for visual analysis of concordance between control and arrhythmia readings showed that agreement was "excellent" for perfusion, "good" for motion, and "marginal" for thickening. CONCLUSIONS: As with quantitative measurements, thickening is the parameter most prone to error in the presence of arrhythmias. It is important to test data for gating errors to avoid potentially erroneous measurements and visual readings.

Three-dimensional color-modulated display of myocardial SPECT perfusion distributions accurately assesses coronary artery disease.

UNLABELLED: The objective of this study was to compare visual assessment of 3-dimensional color-modulated (to counts) surface displays with visual assessment of oblique tomographic slices of myocardial SPECT perfusion distributions in the detection and localization of coronary artery disease (CAD). METHODS: Sixty-two consecutive patients (41 men, 21 women; mean age, 61 +/- 11 y) who had undergone conventional dual-isotope perfusion SPECT were retrospectively chosen; 50 had undergone coronary arteriography previously, and 12 had less than a 5% likelihood of CAD. Four readers interpreted the 3-dimensional displays and slices in separate sessions while unaware of the findings of previous readings, the interpretations of others, and the angiographic results. The readers used a 5-point scoring system. Their average score was used for receiver operating characteristic (ROC) analysis. The area under the ROC curves was determined so that the ability of the 2 methods to detect and localize CAD could be compared. RESULTS: No significant differences were found between visual interpretation of 3-dimensional displays and visual interpretation of slices. CONCLUSION: These preliminary results indicate that visual interpretation of 3-dimensional displays of myocardial perfusion SPECT distributions may someday replace visual assessment of conventional slices without loss of diagnostic accuracy.

Left ventricular function and perfusion from gated SPECT perfusion images: an integrated method.

UNLABELLED: A new technique for computing left ventricular function, including left ventricular volumes, mass and ejection fraction, has been developed. This method is a logical extension of the results of a standard perfusion quantification technique; thus, it allows integration of perfusion and functional information. METHODS: Anatomically based models of the endocardial and epicardial surfaces are generated using the myocardial samples for which perfusion values are quantified, for all frames in the cardiac cycle. With these surface points, left ventricular chamber volume and myocardial volume can be computed. A computer simulation was used to determine the sensitivity of the approach to the assumptions of the model. Validation of volume, mass and ejection fraction was performed with correlative MR studies, and ejection fraction and left ventricular volumes were further investigated using correlative first-pass studies. RESULTS: Automated processing was successful in 96% of the cases analyzed. End diastolic volume, end systolic volume, left ventricular mass and left ventricular ejection fraction correlated with MRI with r = 0.97, 0.99, 0.87, and 0.85, respectively. Ejection fraction from tomography correlated with first-pass values with r = 0.82, and end diastolic and end systolic volumes from tomography correlated with first-pass values with r = 0.85 and r = 0.91, respectively. CONCLUSION: The new integrated approach is accurate and robust for computing both perfusion and function from perfusion tomograms.

A quantitative evaluation of the three dimensional reconstruction of patients' coronary arteries.

BACKGROUND: Through extensive training and experience angiographers learn to mentally reconstruct the three dimensional (3D) relationships of the coronary arterial branches. Graphic computer technology can assist angiographers to more quickly visualize the coronary 3D structure from limited initial views and then help to determine additional helpful views by predicting subsequent angiograms before they are obtained. METHODS: A new computer method for facilitating 3D reconstruction and visualization of human coronary arteries was evaluated by reconstructing biplane left coronary angiograms from 30 patients. The accuracy of the reconstruction was assessed in two ways: 1) by comparing the vessel's centerlines of the actual angiograms with the centerlines of a 2D projection of the 3D model projected into the exact angle of the actual angiogram; and 2) by comparing two 3D models generated by different simultaneous pairs on angiograms. The inter- and intraobserver variability of reconstruction were evaluated by mathematically comparing the 3D model centerlines of repeated reconstructions. RESULTS: The average absolute corrected displacement of 14,662 vessel centerline points in 2D from 30 patients was 1.64 +/- 2.26 mm. The average corrected absolute displacement of 3D models generated from different biplane pairs was 7.08 +/- 3.21 mm. The intraobserver variability of absolute 3D corrected displacement was 5.22 +/- 3.39 mm. The interobserver variability was 6.6 +/- 3.1 mm. CONCLUSIONS: The centerline analyses show that the reconstruction algorithm is mathematically accurate and reproducible. The figures presented in this report put these measurement errors into clinical perspective showing that they yield an accurate representation of the clinically relevant information seen on the actual angiograms. These data show that this technique can be clinically useful by accurately displaying in three dimensions the complex relationships of the branches of the coronary arterial tree.

Clinical validation of three-dimensional color-modulated displays of myocardial perfusion.

BACKGROUND: Two-dimensional polar maps have been validated previously with coronary arteriography for determining vascular involvement of defects from a patient's myocardial perfusion distributions with and without quantification. The purpose of this study was to validate previously developed three-dimensional color-modulated surface displays representing myocardial perfusion. METHODS AND RESULTS: The validation consisted of comparing the agreement between the three-dimensional displays and two-dimensional polar maps in localizing perfusion defects to vascular territories in 30 patients (16 men/14 women) who underwent both a 1-day rest/stress exercise 99mTc-labeled sestamibi study and coronary arteriography. Reading by two experts was used to identify the size and location of quantified defects and corresponding areas of reversibility seen in the polar maps and, on a separate day, in the three-dimensional displays. Agreement between the two-dimensional polar maps and the three-dimensional displays resulted in identical percentages for the localization of both defects and reversibilities: left anterior descending coronary artery, 87% (26/30); left circumflex coronary artery, 97% (29/30); right coronary artery, 97% (29/30); and coronary artery disease, 97% (29/30). CONCLUSIONS: These results show that the color-modulated three-dimensional displays are at least as good as the CEqual polar maps in localizing a perfusion defect and its reversibility to angiographically defined vascular territories and thus could be used in the routine clinical evaluation of myocardial perfusion.

Prognosis in patients with left ventricular apical aneurysm diagnosed by thallium-201 or Tc-99m sestamibi SPECT images.

The prognosis of patients with left ventricular (LV) aneurysm diagnosed by thallium single-photon emission computed tomography (Tl-SPECT) or technetium-99m sestamibi SPECT (MIBI) has not previously been defined. Of 9,505 Tl or MIBI patients, 139 with apical infarct and probable LV aneurysm on tomographic images were identified. Patients were grouped by the presence of divergent versus parallel LV walls. Divergent walls show increasing separation of the walls as they approach the apex on vertical or horizontal long-axis slices. The degree of the deformation at the apex (divergent vs parallel walls), extent of impaired myocardium (total number of pixels in the defect/total number of pixels in the myocardium x 100%), percentage of reversibility, and segmental and total severity of standard deviations of perfusion defects were calculated. Seventy-six patients underwent contrast ventriculography. Patients with divergent walls (n = 57) were older (p = 0.05), had lower ejection fractions (p = 0.012), higher lung uptake (only Tl patients (p = 0.06), and more frequent ST elevation on the resting electrocardiogram (p = 0.009) than patients with nondivergent (parallel) walls. For both groups, the percent impaired myocardium was comparably high (44 +/- 9% vs 46 +/- 10%). Analysis of asynergic segments in 76 patients who underwent contrast ventriculography showed more akinetic, paradoxical, or aneurysmal segments in the apical region of the left ventricle in the group with SPECT divergent walls. Cox model analysis showed divergence as the significant correlate of death. At 5 years, survival for the group with divergent walls was 52% compared with 75% for those with nondivergent walls (p = 0.008). Despite significant apical LV impairment in both groups, mortality was almost twice as high in the group with divergent walls compared with patients with parallel walls. Thus, patients with LV aneurysm diagnosed by radionuclide SPECT perfusion imaging have a higher mortality when displaying a divergent wall pattern than patients with lesser deformity.

Three-dimensional displays of left ventricular epicardial surface from standard cardiac SPECT perfusion quantification techniques.

UNLABELLED: Two methods for generating left ventricular epicardial surface from SPECT perfusion tomograms are described and validated. Both methods use the locations of the maximal reconstructed count values determined from a perfusion quantification procedure as a basis for generating surfaces. METHODS: The first method fits circular contours, which are perpendicular to the long-axis, to the points obtained from perfusion quantification. The second method applies median and linear filters to the points to remove noise but maintain the basic shape of the surface. Both models are validated against an automatic technique and against the user-traced surfaces of both the perfusion image and an MR image of the same patient. RESULTS: The median-filtered model was found to be closer to the standard surfaces than the circular model in all cases, and 85% of the points on the median-filtered surfaces were within one SPECT pixel length of the hand-traced MR surfaces. CONCLUSION: Accurate, three-dimensional left ventricular epicardial surfaces can be generated quickly and easily from already existing perfusion quantification software. The resulting images may be useful for realistic displays of ventricular size, shape and the three-dimensional distribution of perfusion.

Determining the accuracy of calculating systolic wall thickening using a fast Fourier transform approximation: a simulation study based on canine and patient data.

UNLABELLED: The high court yields of 99mTc-sestamibi make possible the acquisition of multiple gated SPECT studies with relatively high count densities. By reorienting these studies into gated short-axis slices, and extracting the three-dimensional myocardial perfusion distribution, we can study wall thickening using an amplitude and phase analysis methodology that examines the change in counts throughout the cardiac cycle. There have been two main concerns raised about this count-based technique: (1) What effect does the sampling rate have on the calculation of systolic wall thickening? and (2) What effect does count density have on the calculation of systolic wall thickening? METHODS: We designed a simulation study using myocardial wall thickening data obtained from ultrasonic crystals implanted in the myocardium of a normal canine. This data was modified to produce wall thickening curves with various percent systolic wall thickening measurements, sampling rates and count densities. RESULTS: The results show that using at least eight frames per cardiac cycle, systolic wall thickening can be calculated with enough accuracy to separate normal patients from those with cardiac dysfunction, even in areas of hypoperfused myocardium. Also, the results show the importance of calculating and interpreting phase (onset of contraction) information. CONCLUSIONS: This count-based technique continues to show promise as a tool for calculating systolic wall-thickening from multiple gated myocardial perfusion SPECT studies, but needs to be validated in a prospective multi-center trial before being applied in a clinical setting.

Multicenter trial validation for quantitative analysis of same-day rest-stress technetium-99m-sestamibi myocardial tomograms.

UNLABELLED: The accuracy of an automated quantitative analysis of same-day rest/stress 99mTc sestamibi SPECT images for detection and localization of coronary artery disease (CAD) was assessed in a multicenter trial consisting of 161 patients from 7 different clinical sites utilizing various camera computer systems. METHODS: Of the 161 patients, 102 had angiographically documented coronary artery disease, 22 had normal coronary arteriograms, and 37 had a low (< 5%) likelihood of coronary artery disease based on their age, sex, symptoms and the results of their exercise electrocardiograms. The patients were studied using previously optimized image acquisition and processing protocols. An additional population consisting of 45 patients with single-vessel disease were evaluated to determine the optimal criteria for detection of CAD. RESULTS: The quantitative analysis method was associated with an overall sensitivity of 87%, specificity of 36%, and normalcy rate (true negative rate in the low likelihood patients) of 81%. Sensitivity for overall detection of disease was similar (90%) in patients with and without myocardial infarction (90% versus 89%). The sensitivities and specificities for identification of disease in individual coronary arteries were, respectively, 69% and 76% for LAD, 70% and 80% for LCX, and 77% and 85% for RCA. CONCLUSION: The results of this study demonstrate that the new objective quantitative method for analysis of same-day rest/stress 99mTc sestamibi SPECT images is accurate for detection and localization of CAD and correlates highly with expert visual interpretation.

Quantitative same-day rest-stress technetium-99m-sestamibi SPECT: definition and validation of stress normal limits and criteria for abnormality.

Gender-matched stress normal limits and criteria for abnormality for rest-stress 99mTc-sestamibi same-day myocardial perfusion imaging were developed and validated in 160 patients who were imaged using previously developed optimized acquisition, processing and quantitative protocols. The gender-matched mean and standard deviation of the normal response were calculated using 35 male and 25 female patients with a < 5% likelihood of coronary artery disease. Receiver-operating curve analysis using expert visual interpretation as the "gold standard" was used to determine the optimal criteria for abnormality detection, in terms of standard deviations from the mean and minimum defect size for each of the four major zones of the polar map, in a pilot population consisting of an additional 35 male and 25 female patients with a variety of perfusion defects. The optimum standard deviations resulted in the following true-positive/true-negative rates when quantitative results were compared to visual analysis for the anterior, septal, lateral, and inferior segments in the combined male and female pilot populations: 84%/86%, 70%/75%, 86%/76% and 69%/76%, respectively. The final criteria were then applied to a prospective population consisting of 33 male and 7 female patients. This analysis resulted in the following true-positive/true-negative rates for overall perfusion abnormalities and abnormalities of the LAD, LCX and RCA vascular territories: 97%/67%, 94%/73%, 73%/90% and 72%/91%, respectively. The optimized 99mTc-sestamibi stress normal limits and criteria for abnormality correlate well with expert visual interpretation of stress myocardial perfusion defects.

Three-dimensional display of cardiac single photon emission computed tomography.

Similar to other cardiac imaging modalities, the quest for a three-dimensional display that can be used for visualizing cardiac single photon emission, computed tomography studies has resulted in several techniques: surface shading, surface modeling, and volume rendering. Each of these techniques has its own advantages and disadvantages. Surface shading yields displays that can be used to enhance a patient's or referring clinician's understanding of a diagnosis, but they are rarely used for diagnostic purposes. Surface modeling yields images that can easily be used for diagnostic purposes, but at present have only been applied to cardiac imaging because of the difficulty of modeling other organs. Volume rendering, in some forms, is beginning to be used diagnostically for some hot-spot imaging procedures, but these are basically refined planar procedures and do not yet have application in quantitative tomography. Because of each technique's unique advantages, each will likely appear in some form in clinical cardiovascular nuclear medicine in the future.

Three-dimensional coronary angiography.

For at least two decades coronary cine-angiograms have been reviewed on film projectors. The cardiologist most often reviews the multiple two-dimensional projections of the coronary arterial tree on a screen, and then mentally create a three-dimensional (3-D) model of the patient's arteries. The ability to synthesize this data and grasp the three-dimensionality of a patient's specific anatomy is quite difficult and requires extensive training and experience to perfect. Fortunately, with advances in computer hardware and software, cardiologists, with all levels of experience, will have assistance with this difficult task. It is now possible, with the use of computers, to reconstruct and display a patient's coronary angiogram in 3-D, allowing the cardiologist to review this data in ways not previously available. In the near future, enhancements in the technique will allow this technology to be placed on-line, directly in the cardiac catheterization laboratory, greatly facilitating the ability to diagnose abnormalities and more appropriately plan treatment strategies.

Technical aspects of myocardial SPECT imaging with technetium-99m sestamibi.

Most reports to date using single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) with technetium-99m (Tc-99m) sestamibi have used acquisition parameters that were optimized for thallium-201. To fully utilize the superior imaging characteristics of Tc-99m sestamibi, there is a need to optimize the technical aspects of SPECT imaging for this agent. Performance can be enhanced through the careful selection of optimal radiopharmaceutical doses, imaging sequences, acquisition parameters, reconstruction filters, perfusion quantification methods and multidimensional methods for visualizing perfusion distribution. The current report describes theoretical considerations, phantom studies and preliminary patient results that have led to optimized protocols, developed at Emory University and Cedars-Sinai Medical Center, for same-day rest-stress studies, given existing instrumentation and recommended dose limits. The optimizations were designed to fit a low-dose-high-dose rest-stress same-day imaging protocol. A principal change in the acquisition parameters compared with previous Tc-99m sestamibi protocols is the use of a high-resolution collimator. The approach is being developed in both prone and supine positions. A new method for extracting a 3-dimensional myocardial count distribution has been developed that uses spherical coordinates to sample the apical region and cylindrical coordinates to sample the rest of the myocardium. New methods for visualizing the myocardial distribution in multiple dimensions are also described, with improved 2-dimensional, as well as 3- and 4-dimensional (3 dimensions plus time) displays. In the improved 2-dimensional display, distance-weighted and volume-weighted polar maps are used that appear to significantly improve the representation of defect location and defect extent, respectively.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Visualization of multimodality cardiac imagery.

A large number of clinically important and medically difficult decisions in diagnostic radiology involve interpreting the information derived from multiple imaging modalities. This is especially true in the assessment of heart disease, wherein at least two types of image information are generally required prior to deciding on the course of action: structural information describing coronary vessel anatomy and functional information related to heart muscle physiology. This paper will present and discuss the methods and results associated with a research program aimed at quantifying and visualizing the unified anatomic and physiologic information obtained from these complementary imaging modalities. The discussions will emphasize the reconstruction, processing, and visualization of three-dimensional cardiovascular structure, including the procedures and results obtained from phantom and patient studies.